There is precious little innovation in the firearms industry. With few notable exceptions, just about any new pistol is little more than a cosmetic makeover of another. But sometimes a company makes a bold move and releases something truly new and different. The results may be good or not so good, but disruption is a worthy goal.
Hudson is a new gun company, founded by Cy and Lauren Hudson. Their first pistol is the Hudson H9 chambered in 9mm. It’s an interesting attempt at creating a pistol with 1911-style geometry, but in a low-bore, striker-fired package and without all the crummy external controls. It’s the kind of Frankenstein creation that many gun enthusiasts have wished for and joked about for years. The H9 would seem to be the first serious attempt at realizing this fantastical ideal.
The Hudson H9 is interesting and I mean that in both the positive and negative senses of the term. Being the first of its kind, it is due both thorough exploration and likely much criticism. That’s the nature of going first. Pioneers take plenty of arrows and after spending some time this month shooting the H9 I aim to shoot a few arrows myself.
Why Consider the Hudson H9?
As a first for me, and unlike every other review I’ve written, I’m going to suggest that one should consider the Hudson H9 almost exclusively for its novelty and not for any specific use purpose. I say this because I cannot think of a specific purpose this pistol serves beyond representing an interesting exploration of new configuration.
The H9 is likely too large and too heavy to serve well as a concealed-carry tool. Its oddly-shaped forward frame means that any rail accessory, like a flashlight or laser, will produce an awkward pistol to holster for duty carry. Otherwise, duty carry could be a relevant consideration for this pistol, but I say that with reservation: this pistol configuration is as yet unproven and perhaps not optimal. I note that given its weight, good sights, and flat-shooting traits, one possible employment could be as a stock competition gun.
Hudson H9 Specs:
- Caliber: 9x19mm
- Length: 7.625”
- Height: 5.225”
- Width: 1.24”
- Barrel: 4.28”
- Trigger: ~5 pounds
- Sights: Anti-glare iron rear, Trijicon HD front
- Weight: 34 oz. w/empty magazine
- Frame: Steel
- Slide/Frame Finish: Black nitride
- Capacity: 15+1
- MSRP: ~$1,147
Before Shooting the Hudson H9
As there was a lot of buzz surrounding the H9 before it came to market, there was sure to be a lot of gossip about it after the fact. When talking to folks who had the chance to shoot it, and before I had that chance, almost to a man they told me that the H9 shoots low. The general consensus is that the front sight is too tall, resulting in a low point of impact vs. aim. I was therefore expecting to experience this same issue. As I’ll detail below, I did not…with an asterisk…
Shooting the Hudson H9
The Hudson website refers to their new pistol saying, “From its steel frame, to its straight-pull trigger, to its striker-fired design the H9 will feel instantly familiar to firearms enthusiasts.” I call false advertizing: there is nothing familiar feeling about shooting the H9. This is something different.
The recoil impulse is different. As compared to the 9mm 1911s I’ve shot, the recoil impulse is pretty strong. Having said that, there is very little muzzle flip with the H9 as compared to a 1911. I’ll attribute this to the deliberate and interesting placement of the recoil spring assembly, which rides low, inside the frame and just in front of the trigger guard. This lower placement of the recoil spring directs the impulse, in part, lower into your hand. However, the spring’s placement necessitates a shorter spring assembly, which allows for a bigger kick (I believe).
Right off the bat the pistol experienced a malfunction, as it failed to feed the first round of the first magazine when I slingshot the slide. I tapped the back of the slide and it went into battery, loading the first round. I saw no hiccups after that. My first shots were not consistent and I later attributed this inconsistent shot placement to the odd trigger construction and action. The H9’s trigger has a full-width shoe/safety that compresses upward, as it is hinged at the bottom. This action is unlike any other trigger on any pistol. The rest of the trigger press is, like that of a 1911, straight back. After the safety shoe takeup, there is very little travel before the crisp break. However, the odd, bottom-hinged safety action tends to result in an odd-feeling press action and perhaps compensatory hand manipulation. It is this odd mechanic to which I attribute the low hits so common to folks who have shot the Hudson H9.
In short order I was able to correct my tendency to use a different press action and accuracy returned. I soon found the H9 to be as accurate as most pistols I’ve shot. Granted, I only took the H9 out to 15 yards, but I was able to get good groups while firing multiple shots at less-than-a-second intervals. The bright front sight certainly helps with mechanical accuracy. Note that I did not do any bench-rest shooting to test the true precision of the H9.
Comfort & Controllability
The grip of the Hudson H9 is chunkier than I imagined it would be. But after all, it is still a double-stack pistol. The lack of grip contour on the front and back makes this not a terribly comfortable gun to hold, but it’s not particularly uncomfortable either. My medium-sized hands could get decent purchase, but I felt like my trigger finger needed to be slightly longer. Perhaps this is something that smaller grip shells (something coming in the future) could mitigate.
One thing I don’t like about the H9 is the flat and slick forward frame. There is neither contour nor texture for the support-hand thumb to gain purchase to help manage the recoil motion. As a result, I got more muzzle flip than I wanted, but this is not a gun that has much muzzle flip in the first place so the result was not as bad as one might expect. I expect that the relatively low bore axis and lowered recoil spring location has something to do with this. The recoil is a bit stiff for such a heavy gun, but it is rather flat shooting and easy to get the excellent sights back on target immediately.
The slide lock mechanism is kind of touchy, resulting in the pistol going into battery most times when a new magazine is inserted. It also results in the slide slipping into battery when you gently set a cleared and open pistol down on the bench. This happened to me a few times. I’d prefer a surer locking mechanism.
Components and Materials
The Hudson H9’s frame is steel and the forward slide configuration is large, which makes for quite a heavy gun. The grip shells can eventually be replaced so one will soon be able to configure the size and texture to suit. As is, the gun is a bit slick and I would not want to run it in the rain or if I had sweaty or bloody hands.
As mentioned earlier, the trigger is an odd bird. The action is straight back, similar to a 1911 trigger. However, the first press movement is the finger closing the safety/shoe onto the trigger body. This safety is hinged at the bottom so the safety moves at the top rather than at the bottom, as all other trigger safeties work. The result is a trigger press that makes the Hudson H9 feel like no gun ever made. I believe this “upside down” feel is responsible for most folks shooting low with the H9. The trigger reset is very short and quite pleasing.
The sights are excellent. The rear is serrated and blacked out and the front is a Trijicon HD sight that is highly visible and certainly helps with proper aim when shooting. Both are dovetailed and one assumes replacements will eventually be available (though likely not necessary!).
I found the external controls to all be well located for my medium-sized hands. The reversible mag release and ambidextrous slide-lock controls will be a boon to some folks. The one component that I think is just poorly done is the slide serration. I don’t care about the front serrations, but the rear serrations are rather mild, shallow, and slick. I found it easy to miss my grip and fail to cycle the slide sometimes.
Conclusions
Pros
With its straight movement and short reset, the trigger is great to run during fast-string shooting. The sights are excellent and the overall aesthetic, the chunky nose aside, is handsome. The recoil impulse, while stiff, is not accompanied by much muzzle flip. The Hudson H9 is an interesting exploration of a concept. I give Hudson props for jumping in with both feet in this admirable effort.
Cons
Unfortunately, I think this gun is a solution to a problem that does not exist. The H9 does not approximate the soft-shooting action of a 9mm 1911. The grip lacks any ergonomic contours. The trigger, while having some good qualities, feels odd to engage and I believe this causes sympathetic hand manipulation during the press. The slide serrations are nowhere near aggressive enough. This is quite a heavy pistol and…it’ll cost you $1,200 bucks!
So for rating the Hudson H9…
Shootability (***)
The interesting trigger is not smooth enough and has a weird-feeling press that I believe compels inaccuracy. However, the gun stays relatively flat when firing and the stock sights are excellent. Ambi controls are in the right spots.
Ergonomics (***)
The Hudson H9 is not a very ergonomic pistol. The ambi controls are a plus, but the grip is like a shovel’s handle.
Accuracy (****)
I found the H9 to be hard to shoot accurately at first, but later found my groove. I’d say it’s as accurate as a Glock 17.
In Summary
The Hudson H9 is a gun that someone needed to make. I called it a solution to a problem that does not exist, but it is the answer to a question many have had for a long time. I believe that Hudson did a pretty good job here, but there’s just too much that is not yet right, in my opinion. The concept may have legs, but Hudson needs to stretch them a bit before I’ll be sold on a gun like this. Designing toward a specific purpose would be a great next step. At present, this gun has no specific purpose for existing, beyond novelty.
* * *







Perfect i believe a same
I got all I wanted to know before buying a hudson h9. Thanks for sharing such a detailed review. Keep it up
I’ve never shot a pistol before and went searching for some information. With no knowledge of pistols I found this review to be very informative and fair. A good read for sure..thank you
Is there a laser in the front end? If not why shape it like that? what a waste. oh, and while on the subject of a laser what gun make is finally going to incorporate a laser and do it right?
Right as in activation via a frame mounted button ala crimson trace or even a trigger actuated laser via a light pressure on the trigger or a metal strip on the front of the trigger so it activates via touch?
Yes Yes YES… I know a trigger activated laser will probably never happen due to liability. So put the button down below the trigger guard like the crimson trace does.
WAKE UP HUDSON, laser targeting is the future.
~
The reason it is shaped like that is so the recoil spring can be lower. Moving the recoil spring lower means they can lower the barrel.
With the barrel lower, it means it should shoot with less felt recoil, and muzzle flip.
Since it is fully steel, it should also have mitigated recoil since it’s heavier.
For snowflakes who don’t actually know how to shoot…
@ bobCAT RE: “laser targeting is the future.” Yes, sadly, laser targeting is absolutely the future…laser targeting is the future for the ever growing population of ignorant Bubbas who are all too eager to OWN and/or CARRY a firearm, but won’t put the time/effort into ACTUALLY LEARNING HOW TO EFFECTIVELY AND PROFICIENTLY OPERATE SAID FIREARM. This brand of laziness often goes hand in hand with the uber responsible practice of opting to forgo any proper education RE: the ACTUAL laws and/or basic safety protocol associated with the responsibility of possessing such an item..
Or… sometimes, due to no fault of their own, are simply just another unfortunate statistic, receiving a lifetime weekly social security disability check, further reiterating why first cousins should NOT bump uglies. But, on the bright side, your tribe of mongoloids are also, historically, the first fools to end up losing a thumb or their life via an entirely avoidable, amateur hour, basic Betty, remedial as all heck, safety misstep. So yes, lasers all around bobby!!! I’ll be eating my popcorn, and watching the Darwin Awards as they are awarded.😂😂😂😂👍🦕💨
I have a lot of firearms from sig to cz to 1911 and I bought this gun a fun gun to shoot for me! I put 1k rounds with no problems! Bottom line and this is a fact MOST PEOPLE CANT SHOOT WELL! I love this gun!
Nice good to hear cause I’m getting one
To me this gun is a point of aim shooter for quick draw and doing the 2-1 shots for CQB. The angle of the grip makes you naturally point to target when you push your arm toward your threat. The low muzzle rise allows for quick second shot and for the third shot to head you would basically cover their head with the front sight, so aim 12 o’clock of the ocular 2×4 area. The manufacturer said the center of the front Trijicon is the intended impact sight not the lollipop (6 o’clock) look that a lot of guns use. I own one and so far no issues. I am concerned by one thing though and that is the spring slowly unscrewing after shooting a lot. I just marked the spring guide rod using a sharpie to the slide so if I see movement I will use the red lock-tight they recommend if this happens. To me this gun has a niche, it is called innovation. Everyone has been producing the same gun for over and over again just different name and face. This gun is trying something new with 6-7 patents for….innovation. Mark my words, if Hudson is the only gun manufacturer who is willing to think out side the box, then they will have a huge advantage over everyone in the future. I bet you every major manufacturer has bought one and is probably right now reverse engineering it and looking at any reviews of the the gun so they can “fix” some of the issues people are seeing, like an un-captured spring guide rod for example, and trying to figure out how to work around the patents Hudson has applied for.
I’m glad I waited. Hudson coming out with the H9A, lighter,fiber optic front sight, different grips..
H9 owner here and I love mine! I can’t wait until I can get my hands on the H9A. I’ve actually dealt with their customer service…i emailed a question and received an answer pretty quickly from them providing the information requested. For those people who talk about their customer service, my experience in that department was great. I also appreciate their integrity as a small business and their dedication remain professional. There were attacking comments related to production and shipping prior to the H9 shipping to dealers and Hudson MFG and what the public didn’t know what there were issues behind the scenes with suppliers holding parts hostage. Once cleared by attorneys, Hudson MFG issued a public statement addressing it. I’m rooting for Hudson MFG and can’t wait to see what they bring to the table as they keep advancing.
“However, the odd, bottom-hinged safety action tends to result in an odd-feeling press action and perhaps compensatory hand manipulation. It is this odd mechanic to which I attribute the low hits so common to folks who have shot the Hudson H9.”
Maybe, but many have confirmed that the stock sights (as nice as they are) were specc-ed to incorrect heights. The Hudson owners have even admitted as much in an interview (the InRangeTV channel on youtube).
For me, what puts me off dropping a grand on a startup company like this is that their QC seems all over the place. Accuracy problems (beyond point of impact/point of aim) have been reported and ascribed to loose barrel lockup. Others have reported gritty triggers and reliability problems.
For me, the local H9 that I tried had probably the worst trigger feel of any stock handgun I’ve handled. No exaggeration. It was mushy and had almost no perceptible reset, tactile or audible. It made the Gen 1 M&Ps triggers seem like perfection. Now, given that other H9 triggers (judging by both reviews and YouTube videos) do not have this reset problem, I must conclude that Hudson QC is simply inconsistent. And in that light, I have to assume that other poor specimens have like gone out the door as well.
I’m not prepared to write Hudson off entirely (it’s still a very cool design), but they need a year or two to sort themselves out and decide how/where the H9 fits in. Want the H9 to be a competition gun?–needs better barrel fitment and a better trigger; RMR mounting options too. Want the H9 to be a duty gun?–needs to be user serviceable and at a much lower price point. Want it to be a fun range gun?–well, it is probably mostly there, though the price point would tempt me to just go with an STI. So maybe the H9 is just a fancy SD gun and weekend warrior gun?–the H9 could probably dominate stock service in local IDPA.
I have to say that I’m a bit confused regarding the comment here of “the worst trigger feel of any stock handgun I’ve handled.” Whaaat?? Hands down, this gun has the best trigger I’ve ever felt on a stock handgun, better than the CZ P10 C, which is saying a lot, because that’s a great trigger. The initial trigger break is crisp, and the reset is incredibly short, positive, and clearly tactile and audible.
Pistol sucks…ive lent it to friends, not one person has any desire to buy one. Trigger stinks up the room.
Just picked one up in lampasses, TX. Love it. Feels great in my hand, shoots just fine for me and I’ve had none of the issues people have complained about. I am always curious when I read comments from the internet, because it seems majority of people who leave replies in the comment section seem to be just bashing to bash. With no experience with the actual firearm in question. When it comes to feel, it’s all subjective. Don’t like it, don’t buy it. Personaly I think a lot of the bashing comes from the price and the fact that it is out of range for some people to purchase so they will just hate on the firearm from preconceived notions based on other’s reviews and not of their own experience. Because If you read the comments on this gun from different sources there must be millions of them out there.
This gun is EXTREMELY expensive for a gun that does not provide anything revolutionary or even remarkable in the shooting world and when there are better guns to be had for less money. At first glance, It looks like an integrally-suppressed 9mm. If i were, then maybe $1,200 would be justified.
If I wanted to drop $1,200 on a 1911 9mm, I’d choose a Kimber or a Springfield EMP. However, if I wanted the most accurate shooting 9mm pistol I’ve ever fired that also had a great trigger, it would be a Springfield XD Mod-2 5″ Tactical model for half the price of a Hudson H9.
The next $1200 gun I buy will be a CZ Shadow 2. Great trigger and very accurate. And looks terrific! But my CZ TSO and Pardini GT45 have AMAZING triggers. But for the biggest bang for the buck, get a Canik SFx and install a Freedomsmith Fat Daddy trigger. 1/8” take up and reset, 2.5 lb break.
Maybe some of you don’t shoot much… or don’t shoot in forced stress situations because I can’t find a single negative thing wrong with the Hudson steel frame I shot for the first time last night.
When I worked as a cardiac medic for 37 years often the instructors were the worst medics in the ambulance… too locked in to textbooks and the same practice scenarios all the tims.
This gun feels, handles and shoots like a dream. The trigger in the one I shot (unmodified) was as perfect I’ve ever felt on a factory gun, similar to my Walther PPQ M2 .45 or maybe my Sig Mk25 with the SRT added. I’m ordering one next payday with five extra mags and the threaded barrel cause I have a bunch of toys for such barrels.
Writer…. you got this one wrong on several overly technical and not field expediancy issues.
I purchased this firearm a few months ago and believe it was money well spent. The H9 truly is like nothing I have fired before. At first my groupings were not to my liking and failed to battery at least 10 times for my first 100 rounds straight out of the box. I was not impressed and felt it was a complete waste. I went home cleaned her up and went back at it a day later. I adjusted my grip a tad and fired 300 rounds. My placement was dead on with rapid fire and tactical reloads and had zero malfunctions. You literally are back on target with little effort once you learn not to fight it’s feel. It is very simple, the recoil is different and at first throws off your placement because it is so completely different. It needs proper care if you intend to use it. Out of the box it is garbage. Cleaned up and properly lubricated, it’s a dream come true.
These things are selling new for $850 now. Glad I passed when I first saw it arrive at Eagle Gun Range. Novelty, but not for $1200.
Buyer beware.
I purchased the H9 for $799 with extra mags at $22 each. This is after the bankruptcy. The gun is quite accurate. It shoots very soft, softer than my gas assisted blowback Wilson ADP, my next softest shooter.
With a traditional sight picture the pistol shoots low at 10 yards with 115 gr and 124 gr loads, about 3 to 4 inches. To hit on you must level the top of the front sight with the rear sight and place the tritium dot over your target, obscuring your target.
Two other shooters at my club had the same results. One of them has shot Distinguished Pistol several times at Camp Perry. He has forgotten more about accurate handgun shooting than I will ever learn.
Anyone care to tell me how much taller a rear sight I need to get to a traditional sight picture?